Rhino Records HomeStore News And Notes Fun About Rhino Help My Cart
CDs DVD and Video Vinyl Store Collectibles: Rhino HandmadeWireless: Music for your cell phone
Newsletter

Sign up here and we'll let you know what’s up

(optional)
HTML Text
More Lefsetz Articles

[3] comments


The Lefsetz Letter

Holly Holy

by Bob Lefsetz

I got on a Neil Diamond kick.

Reading about his fantastic live business my synapses fired, I needed to hear him RIGHT NOW!

Turns out I only had "Cherry, Cherry" in my iTunes library. I distinctly remember downloading all his hits, where WERE they? Must have been when I rebuilt my hard drive three times in a week back in 2000. I couldn't figure out the error messages. Ultimately turns out it was a bad RAM chip. But I wasn't worried about trashing my hard drive, I could just go back onto Napster and get the MP3s I lost almost INSTANTLY!

Napster was a club. Made up of everybody who loved music. Pre-teens to grandparents. Anybody who wasn't afraid of technology, who could use a computer. I found obscure stuff on the service that I haven't been able to locate since. Tracks that were never released on CD, that I'd worn out the vinyl of.

Nothing as good exists today. Oh, BitTorrent's fine if you want something new or big or both. But if you're a fan, a BELIEVER, you're frustrated. Stuff like Danny Wilde's "The Boyfriend" isn't on iTunes. But Neil Diamond, you can get Neil Diamond. It comes down almost INSTANTLY P2P!

Of course I needed "Sweet Caroline". But since it was all free, I took all the hits. I cross-referenced with Amazon. Oh, I remembered some of the hits, like "Brother Love's Traveling Salvation Show", but I needed the Website to jog my memory of "Holly Holy".

You see Neil Diamond started off as a rocker. All energy. Listen to "Cherry, Cherry" and your body starts to pop. What came after...was slowed down and bloated. In an era where FM was taking over, Neil Diamond was someone you heard on AM. And, since you didn't have an FM radio in your car in 1969, you knew his tunes well. And that's how I discovered "Sweet Caroline".

Actually, before that came the aforementioned "Brother Love", in the spring of '69. I taped that from the radio. WDRC in Hartford. I had my Norelco plugged into the back of my Columbia all-in-one stereo. A reverse Y-adapter. Turning stereo into mono. It was a ritual, I'd sit in front of the box and when something came on I wanted I pushed record. Of course, I didn't get the whole song, and that's how I remember it, with the intro cut off. But, listening to my newly-downloaded copy, I was stunned to hear the introductory lines...

"Hot August night
And the leaves hanging down
And the grass on the ground smelling sweet"

So, THAT'S why the legendary live album is entitled "Hot August Night"! WHO KNEW! See, even we people who LIVED through the era can discover things.

And "Brother Love" was good, but not transcendent. There was this certain vocal inflection. And the raucousness of the vocal. But it wasn't in the league of what came after, "Sweet Caroline". It was the intro. The anticipation. With the all the hope, the OPTIMISM of the sixties.

That's when you know you're a true music fan. When you can love something as sappy as "Sweet Caroline". Something on paper that's too ordinary, too bloated, too mainstream, yet sounds so GREAT! You couldn't hear it without singing along with the chorus. The English rockers might have ruled the FM airwaves and concert venues, but "Sweet Caroline" was a king on AM, Mariah Carey's "We Belong Together", but bigger, and better.

Then, "Sweet Caroline" was followed up by "Holly Holy". A denouement in tempo and quality. A bombastic, over the top slow-burner that one could like, but not love. But listen today. Listen today. It's shocking.

Taken out of context, removed from that revolutionary era, "Holly Holy" is a revelation.

You can see the recording session. Everybody in one big room. The piano player. The bass player. The plethora of backup singers. And, in the middle, Neil himself.

Oh, the tune starts with one of those guitar figures off a Glen Campbell record, laconic yet meaningful. And, underneath it, a bass so rich and fat it's as if the musician is plucking Pavarotti. Like there's a fat man with a deep bass voice resonating. Then, as if he's a male Aretha Franklin, Neil starts to croon like he's in church, like his soul depends on it. And then the piano enters, ACCENTING the bass figure. And the great morass of backup singers, culled from far and wide to sing on this track, straight from the gig exercising their pipes on "Oh Happy Day", they sway back and forth and sing in voices just a tad above whisper, but there are so damn MANY of them that it resembles an army, a musical army, one that doesn't kill, but makes people COME ALIVE with its music.

And then they do come alive. They amp it up, they start to expend the energy in their souls. And then come the STRINGS! REAL strings, not the canned type. Oh, they're singing like sopranos. Way up in the upper register. And now, EVERYBODY'S AT NINE!

No, not ten. You know they've got a little bit left. That they can turn on if they want to. This is not Mariah Carey giving it her all, rather real people singing the SONG, not trying to blow you away with their power but the MEANING, the PURE JOY of what they're part of, what they're creating.

"Sing a song
Sing a song of songs
Sing it out
Sing it strong

YEAH!!!!"

It's the "yeah". It's kind of like Don Henley's "Are you with me SO far?" in "Life In The Fast Lane". It reaches OUTSIDE the song. To YOU, in the AUDIENCE! It's pure EXUBERANCE!! You can no longer stay seated, you jump up now too, you've got to PARTICIPATE!

In the best part of the record...

"Call the sun in the dead of the night
And the sun's gonna rise in the sky
Touch a man who can't walk upright
And that lame man, he's gonna flyAnd I flyAnd I fly"

Right in front of your very eyes, Neil's POSSESSED! He's got God in him in a way no pontificating politician ever could. He's writhing, what comes out of his body is pure emotion.

Then they retreat, and do it again.

And finally, almost three minutes and fifty seconds into the song, a kettle drum erupts and everybody finally goes to 10, 11! Everybody's at full force, full volume. It's astounding.

Now, back in the day, we had to stay tuned to the radio. Waiting to hear something again. Now, with the blessing of digital media, we can go straight back to the top, and play a song again. Go from slow to fast, from 0-60, all in under five minutes.

AM had terrible sound. But, our car stereos were even worse. We never heard these songs the way we were supposed to, the way they were cut.

Oh, we bought "Abbey Road" and component stereos. Got infatuated with turntables and cartridges. Bathed in quality sound. But, we didn't buy Neil Diamond albums. At most, we had 45s, which were dirty and scratched up after being beaten to hell on our little record players. But now blemish-free, with subwoofers, even at a low rip rate, the true GENIUS emerges.

Oh, it's not about the lyrics. The music says more than words ever could. And, it's not an intellectual experience anyway. It's emotional. It's happening deep in your heart.

Bob Lefsetz, Santa Monica-based industry legend, is the author of the e-mail newsletter, "The Lefsetz Letter". Famous for being beholden to no one, and speaking the truth, Lefsetz addresses the issues that are at the core of the music business: downloading, copy protection, pricing and the music itself. His intense brilliance captivates readers from Steven Tyler to Rick Nielsen to Bryan Adams to Quincy Jones to EVERYBODY who's in the music business. Never boring, always entertaining, Mr. Lefsetz's insights are fueled by his stint as an entertainment business attorney, majordomo of Sanctuary Music's American division and consultancies to major labels.

While Rhino may occasionally disagree with some of Bob's opinions, we certainly agree with his right to state them. At the bottom of each column we give you, the reader, the opportunity to respond and we encourage you to do so. We will post select comments.


LET US KNOW WHAT YOU THINK.

A word about submissions: We post what you give us, so please don't include your email address or any personal info. Your comments reach Rhino, not necessarily the writer, so don't expect a reply from them (or us, see our help section for contact info). We gather and post your submissions in batches, so do expect a short delay. And don't get bent if we edit your comments. We probably won't, but we reserve that right.


Comments:

Awsome! Awsome! Nice to know, where the "good" ones are! I love your style, let the good-times live on!!!!!!!!! Z.

I remember Neil Diamond being on the radio (yep - AM) as a kid, then by the time I got older, I was onto a sequence of different music phases. Today I had my 2 yr old in the backseat and she likes the radio on so I keep it on an easy listening station. Holly Holy came on and I was just thinking (with a lump in my throat) about how great it sounded when my daughter said "Mommy! This is really good music!" I thought - My God, this really is a phenomenal song. I'm listening to pure creative inspiration. I couldn't even sing along b/c of the lump in my throat! That is why I found this website - I wanted to read more about Neil Diamond. Thank you for your insights - I couldn't agree with you more!

I couldn't agree more. And your last paragraph brought to mind a Neil Diamond song title which, to me, capsulizes what he's all about--"Don't Think...Feel"




Let I Bleed Book

What's Inside the Rhino Magazine

Subscribe to Feed

Subscribe in Bloglines

home :: news & notes :: store :: about rhino :: fun stuff :: help :: my cart :: privacy policy :: terms of service