Big Star inspired a fevered allegiance among fans of power pop, giving rise to a cult of believers who spent decades spreading the gospel. Their enthusiasm turned this obscure Memphis pop band-one that got little airplay, sold few records, and only played a handful of times- into a remarkable rock and roll resurrection story. Big Star's trek from obscure Memphis band to standard bearers for an entire genre of music has never been fully mapped-until now. Rhino presents the definitive look at the definitive power-pop band with a four-disc boxed set divided between key cuts from Big Star's three studio albums and unreleased music.
KEEP AN EYE ON THE SKY spans 1968 to 1975 and shows the progression of Big Star through selections from such studio precursors as Rock City and Icewater; music from Big Star's acclaimed recordings (#1 Record, Radio City, and Third/Sister Lovers); and relevant solo work by group principals Alex Chilton and Chris Bell, who formed Big Star in 1971 with bassist Andy Hummel and drummer Jody Stephens. The collection also uncovers a trove of unreleased demos, unused mixes, alternate versions of songs, and a 1973 concert recorded in Memphis.
In these 98 tracks you can hear what turned artists as diverse as Cheap Trick, R.E.M., and The Replacements into Big Star fans. Spotlighting the band's roots, the boxed set opens with several songs recorded before Big Star formed, including “Try Again,” one of the first songs Bell and Chilton wrote together. Those early cuts are followed by Big Star's 1972 debut #1 Record, reimagined here using a mix of album tracks and unreleased alternate mixes of favorites like “Thirteen,” “When My Baby's Beside Me,” and more. Among the disc's rarities are “Country Morn'” (issued as a flexi-disc single by a Big Star fanzine), the demo for “I Got Kinda Lost,” and an unreleased acoustic demo of Chilton singing Loudon Wainwright's “Motel Blues.”
Ardent Records, the band's label, experienced problems with distribution that hindered any chances at success for #1 Record. Its failure was a major blow to Bell, who quit the band to go solo. In 1974, the Alex Chilton-led Big Star regrouped and released Radio City, an album more attuned to the band's live energy that featured the power-pop confections "September Gurls" and "Back Of A Car." The second disc of KEEP AN EYE ON THE SKY opens with a trio of unreleased demos: "There Was A Light," "What's Going Ahn," and "Life Is White." The original song sequence for Radio City follows, combining album versions with unreleased alternate mixes ("Way Out West" and "You Get What You Deserve.") The disc features unissued versions of "She A Mover" and "Mod Lang," several unreleased demos for Big Star's third album, plus Bell's acclaimed 1978 single "I Am The Cosmos" and its B-side "You And Your Sister." Sadly, Bell died in a car accident a few months after the single's release.
When Big Star reconvened in 1975 to record Third/Sister Lovers, only Chilton and Stephens remained (Hummel left shortly before Radio City's release). Famed Memphis maverick Jim Dickinson was enlisted to supervise the recording, which languished on the shelf for years before its release in 1978. Despite its bleak timbre, wild dynamics, and fragility, the music possesses a startling grace. KEEP AN EYE ON THE SKY's third disc opens with seven demos (most previously unreleased) for songs that appear on Third/Sister Lovers, including "Jesus Christ," "Take Care," and "Holocaust." Among the album's 19 songs collected here is "For You," "Kizza Me," and "Kanga Roo." Also featured is "Lovely Day," an early, unreleased version of "Stroke It Noel" with different lyrics; Chilton with photographer Bill Eggleston at the piano for Nat King Cole's "Nature Boy" and a raucous cover of The Kinks' "Till The End Of The Day."
Big Star inspired a fevered allegiance among fans of power pop, giving rise to a cult of believers who spent decades spreading the gospel. Their enthusiasm turned this obscure Memphis pop band-one that got little airplay, sold few records, and only played a handful of times- into a remarkable rock and roll resurrection story. Big Star's trek from obscure Memphis band to standard bearers for an entire genre of music has never been fully mapped-until now. Rhino presents the definitive look at....
+Read More...
Friday, November 13, 2009 - 1:02 PM
I wouldn't necessarily recommend this box set for a newcomer to Big Star (classics such as "In the Street" and "September Gurls" tend to get drowned out by the extended play of each of these discs), but for existing Big Star fans who already know, own and love their original albums, "Keep an Eye on the Sky" will reinvigorate your admiration for this band. In addition to the amazing sound quality, this collection includes two of Chris Bell’s rare solo recordings of “I Am the Cosmos†and the achingly beautiful “You and Your Sisterâ€. In addition to the abundance of alternate mixes of the original album tracks, there are several acoustic demo’s, most notably “Holocaust†and “You Get What You Deserveâ€, which are interesting to hear in such a raw form. Other treats include inspired live covers of songs by T.Rex, Kinks, Gram Parsons and Todd Rundgren (obvious influences) dispersed amidst a live set which sounds like it was recorded in a small bar—the sound is great for an old live recording, but I found the audience’s apparent lack of attention (are they even paying any attention at times?) to be a bit distracting, and it seems to affect the band too—but it also puts things back into “historical perspectiveâ€: a sad reminder that this was actually an overlooked and unappreciated band during the time of their existence. The 100 page accompanying book of photo’s and in-depth articles gives further insights into this and how they eventually rose to become a cult phenomenon among the college underground music scene of the 80’s and beyond... overall, a nicely done, well-deserved box-set for this highly influential band.
Saturday, November 14, 2009 - 4:59 PM
I would've given this 5 stars if they simply repackaged/remastered the first 3 albums in their original formats, and included separate bonus discs of the demo's, rarities and alternative mixes. Instead, the extras are scattered alongside the original songs, which tend to run in a slightly altered track sequence to the original records. I guess one could argue this was a more approapriate approach to assembling Big Star in a boxed set, but for someone who treasures the cohesive perfection of those first 3 albums, I found it to feel more like a "greatest hits" compilation crossed with a bunch of "works-in-progress". On the other hand, I'm still grateful to have more Big Star in my possession-- the live disc 4 is a major BONUS, and the accompanying long-reading book and photography within is suitable enough for your coffee table-- or better yet, turn to page 40 for a classic picture of Alex Chilton (oh so that's where Paul Westerberg got his look!) suitable for framing and giving to your girlfriend for Christmas... nah, then again, just keep it for yourself.
Sunday, May 2, 2010 - 2:56 PM
I purchased the Big Star box set "Keep an eye on the sky" & discovered to my dismay that disc 3 was missing (disc 2 was duplicated - although labeled as disc 3). I returned it to the retailer (HMV) They replaced it & assured me that the new set was complete. It wasn't. Disc 3 is STILL missing.
In the absence of any contact details on your website, I'm hoping that someone at Rhino actually reads these reviews & gets back to me..Hopefully with disc 3!
Login to write a review!
Review This!